the age of the scar itself matters less than the type and depth of scarring when it comes to how well microneedling will work, so having older scars doesnt automatically mean worse results. what matters more is whether the scarring is more shallow rolling type texture versus deeper ice pick or boxcar type scarring, since the deeper narrower types tend to respond less dramatically to microneedling alone and sometimes benefit from being combined with other treatments. for longstanding shallow to moderate scarring though plenty of people see meaningful improvement even with scars that have been around for many years, since the treatment is really just stimulating your current collagen production regardless of how long the damage has been there. a consultation where the provider actually looks at your specific scarring pattern would give you a much clearer answer than general info online